Episode 21 is all about beauty, joy and music that speaks to our souls.
For arguments sake: where we take a debate, cut out the party politics and try to talk it out
While beauty can be an abstract subject, it’s also something that cuts into our everyday lives. Megan and Michael wanted to talk about this subject because they both feel the evangelical world can feel a bit confining when talking about beauty. Megan says her experience of baptists in particular is that they have a strained relationship with beauty.
“There’s a suspicion of the beautiful, which goes back to the church fathers,” says Michael. Something also happens during the Reformation, when Protestants want to get away from the visual, smash the statues and go back to the verbal. Luther even said that the ears are the organ of the Christian, not the eyes.
Evangelicalism is quite a pragmatic faith. “We’re not cathedral builders,” says Michael. “We want things to make a difference,” says Megan, so the feeling is that there’s no time for “frippery”.
Michael and Megan explore what beauty is – is it just ‘high art’ or is it broader than that? What can nature teach us about beauty? And is there a commonality of the experience of beauty that might be objective truth?
Megan has been reading Culture Care by Makoto Fujimura – an artist, academic and Christian -which issues a call to feed our culture’s soul with beauty, creativity and generosity. As many Christians become more embattled in culture wars, Fujimura is asking how Christians can be people who draw others into beauty.
Also mentioned in this segment:
- The deepening crisis is evangelical Christianity in The Atlantic: “Evangelical Christians need another model for cultural and political engagement, and one of the best I am aware of has been articulated by the artist Makoto Fujimura, who speaks about “culture care” instead of “culture war.”
Where credit’s due: the influences that form and move us
It’s Megan’s turn to pick a book that was meaningful to her: Surprised by Joy by CS Lewis – the story of Lewis being converted to belief in God and then eventually to belief in Christianity.
Lewis’ experience of beauty – which he calls experiences of joy – resonated with Megan, particularly when Lewis talks of creating imaginative worlds with his brothers as a child.
Michael says he picked up on the sense of longing through Lewis’ work – deep in the heart of humans there is something that longs for the eternal.
Beauty, says Megan, shows us that things are significant, special. As the poet Gerard Manley Hopkins writes, “The world is charged with the grandeur of God.”
- Michael has written on beauty for Eternity – Are Christians scared of beauty? and Why is there beauty in the world?
Marg and Dave: reviews from two people obsessed by stories, but not always the same ones.
We’re talking transcendent music and faith. And Michael wants to talk about Bach: “The Christian who has done more to advance the cause of beauty than anyone is Johann Sebastian Bach,” he says.
Megan, on the other hand, says the music that makes her think of beauty is African American spirituals: “there’s a beauty in the sadness, but yet the hope … there’s a beauty that comes out of a the experience of humanity.” One song in particular featured in season 3 of The Handmaid’s Tale during a scene of infant baptism, ‘Down to the river to pray’.
Also mentioned in this segment:
- Well-Tempered Clavier, Bach
- Mass in B Minor, Bach
- O Sacred Head Sore Wounded (From St Matthew’s Passion, Bach)
- Down to the River to Pray, Alison Krauss version as seen on The Handmaid’s Tale
Want to subscribe?
Find out more about the hosts of With All Due Respect:
We got the idea of our two-header theology and culture podcast from this show: The Movie Show/At the Movies.